Ciarán12 wrote: He hasn't a clue how languages work and has no knowledge of grammatical concepts of any kind. He is about as difficult a person to teach a new language to as you are likely to find (with his one saving grace being that he will be willing to learn, even if somewhat begrudgingly).
GrammarIn my experience, most native speakers would be very hard-pressed to present a valid summary of the grammatical concepts underlying their own language ... and this includes university graduates ... and I suspect that your friend, like most of us, has "learned by inference" the rules of grammar for speaking English and that he speaks his native tongue with a very high level of skill.
Even a Moron...I am showing my age here, but this story reminds me of the introductory remark that was once included in the Berlitz Teach Yourself textbooks and that, for understandable reasons, no longer appears. I am working from memory here, but it went something as follows, "So you want to learn a new language? Don't be discouraged, even a moron speaks one!" Okay, you're offended. Or, maybe you've been sensitized to reacting
as if you're offended. The point that the editors of the Berlitz method were trying to make was that, if you can learn one language (your native language), then you can learn another. Your friend is quite capable of learning a second language and he is blessed with having a good attitude and a great buddy!
Resources for Learning IrishFrom my search of the Internet, there does not seem to be a wealth of resources for learning Irish. Nonetheless, I would make the following suggestions:
Travels with TeangoI suppose that I
could re-type all of the links from the attached website and claim credit for having done the research, but that would be cheating and I have always been too lazy to cheat. So, here they are:
https://teango.wordpress.com/a-list-of-resources-for-learning-irish/.
Self-Study CoursesLet's be honest here, most adults embark on their self-study language-learning journeys as either "self-improvement projects" like losing a few extra pounds of flab, or versions of "I'd just like to have a conversation with the waiter" during their next holiday ventures. Since learning a second language represents a much greater challenge than they anticipated, just as losing the flab does, most adults abandon their self-study language courses long before completion. Publishers are quite aware of this and, in response to the "true" market demand, they offer introductory courses that include perhaps 1,000 of the most common "transactional" vocabulary items, a bear hint of the underlying structure of the language, while studiously avoiding the crisis-provoking word "grammar", at best two dozen elementary situational dialogues recorded on 2 CDs, and they contain very few materials for actually practicing the target language. They are, in a word, superficial. From my search of the Internet, these seem to be most palatable materials:
Pimsleur IrishSimon & Schuster offers what could best be described as an "appetizer" to the Irish language. Given the very limited range of the 10-lesson course, even at the present price of 42 $US, it is a little pricy. Nonetheless, as a "confidence builder" for a willing if somewhat reluctant language-learner, it is worth considering. Note carefully that this "appetizer" contains very little vocabulary.
Teach Yourself Complete Irish Generally speaking, the "Teach Yourself" series is well-regarded. A truly industrious student should be able to achieve a CEFR A1 Level with this course. The challenge will be to find additional, progressive, practice materials. Refer to "Teango" above.
Living Language Irish, Complete EditionGenerally speaking, the "Living Language Complete" series is well-regarded. A truly industrious student should be able to achieve a CEFR A1 Level with this course. The challenge will be to find additional, progressive, practice materials. Refer to "Teango" above.
Living Language Spoken World IrishThe Living Language "Spoken World" series aims for a higher level than the "Complete" series. The dialogues are, from the very beginning, of a more complex nature than the latter course. The vocabulary moves beyond the mere transactional. The explanations of grammar assume that the learner actually wants to understand the structure of the language. The course includes 6 CDs as opposed to the customary 2 CDs. I would guess that the level achieved on completion would be somewhere around CEFR A2. Nonetheless, as before, the challenge will be to find additional, progressive, practice materials. Refer to "Teango" above.
Learning Irish (Yale Language)The Yale University Press is noted for supporting serious efforts in language-learning. Based on the university's reputation and the Amazon Customer Reviews, I would consider this little package and, despite the advice of at least one customer, I would track down the audio cassettes that were recorded to accompany this baby.
Some Additional SourcesPlease note that I have
not studied Irish and that I have
no plans to do so. Still, I came across the following sources of information:
HTLAL (How-To-Learn-Any-Language) Discussion ThreadQuite an interesting exposé!
http://how-to-learn-any-language.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=25204And yet, another!
http://how-to-learn-any-language.com/forum/forum_posts.asp?TID=29318&PN=44DuolingoYa can't beat free! Well, you can, actually.
https://www.duolingo.com/Speak Irish NowThey say that their book makes learning Irish easy.
http://www.speakirishnow.com/books.html?gclid=CJm-3Om1w8oCFVEYHwodDXkEhgErin's WebSans commentaire:
http://www.erinsweb.com/gaelic1.htmlLearn Irish GaelicDitto:
http://www.learnirishgaelic.com/Transparent Language
Double Ditto:
http://www.transparent.com/learn-irish/If I come across other materials, I will append them to this post.
A Bridge, Perhaps Not Too Far, But Definitely Off in the Distance From my personal experience, and from that of many language enthusiasts on the Internet, passing an "Oral Exam" in a second language means that the candidate possesses a skill around the CEFR B2 level. For your friend to achieve such a level, he is going to need a
lot of
input in terms of access to both audio and printed materials and he his going to need a
lot of
output in terms of practicing the language with native speakers. On your marks, get set, ...