Wine thshortstop wrote:Has anyone seen in writing (or heard) the letter t where, by "modern orthography", the letter k might be expected? (I already know of otole [rather than okole] and Waititi [used in the 1830s] rather than Waikiki.)
e.g. Tamehameha, rather than Kamehameha.
my advice to everyone is to learn the Niihau dialect and not some book learned Hawaiian which was invented by foreign missionaries. Since some of us with Hawaiian blood hate ha'ores (haoles) so much why would you want to perpetuate their version of our language?
The letters of the Hawaiian alphabet were established in 1826 by a committee of missionaries who used letters to represent the sounds as they heard them. At this time, the change from t to k had begun on the island of Hawai‘i but had not reached Kauai where t was used until comparatively recent times. Colonel Spaulding, from the reports to the American Board of Missions in Boston, prepared a paper read before the Hawaiian Historical Society in 1930 in which he showed how the alphabet was compiled. The committee of nine missionaries took various letters in turn and voted on them. The final report, facetiously headed ‘Report of the Committee of Health on the state of the Hawaiian language’, set forth its conclusions in terms to justify the name assumed by the committee.
The greatest difficulty was experienced in choosing between l and r, k and t, and w and v. ‘K is deemed of sufficient capacity to perform its own functions and that of its counterpart T. L though two pills have been given to expel it is to remain to do its own office and that of its yoke fellow R. R though closely connected with the vitals is expelled by five or six votes or expellants, though nearly the same quantity of preservatives has been applied. T though claiming rights as a native member has suffered amputation by the knife and saw of the majority. V, a contiguous member and claiming similar rights, has suffered the same fate, and a gentle [illegible] has been applied to dry the wounds of both.' Thus the committee of health experts chose l, k, and w, but as r, t, and v are the consonants used in Tahiti, whence the Hawaiians came, I have a feeling that the purgatives and the knife were applied to the wrong patient in each pair.