Daniel, I think that when the thread is not very crowded (the Scots-gaelic thread isn't) it's not much of a problem to leave both class and discussion at the same thread, it's better than crowding the forum with more threads on the same language.
Learning Georgian, Mandarin Chinese, Russian and Papiamentu from scratch. Trying to brush up my Norwegian up to an advanced level.
Well, I'd like a discussion group because there we could try and use Gaelic as much as possible (and not only discuss the language but also other themes) and ask questions more freely (not to mix questions of all sorts with lessons).
I would like a discussion. I'm extremely new to the language (along with it's celtic sisters and brothers) and it helps me a lot. But, on the other hand this isn't one of the popular ones, so I see both sides.